HOW TO TELL THEM FROM OTHER TREES

The pines belong to the coniferous class of trees; that is, trees which bear cones. The pines may be told from the other coniferous trees by their leaves, which are in the form of needles two inches or more in length. These needles keep green throughout the entire year. This is characteristic of all coniferous trees, except the larch and cypress, which shed their leaves in winter.
Coniferous Forest
The pines are widely distributed throughout the Northern Hemisphere, and include about 80 distinct species with over 600 varieties. The species enumerated here are especially common in the eastern part of the United states, growing either native in the forest or under cultivation in the parks. The pines form a very important class of timber trees, and produce beautiful effects when planted in groups in the parks.
Winter Pines


HOW TO TELL THEM FROM EACH OTHER

The pine needles are arranged in clusters; Each species has a certain characteristic number of needles to the cluster and this fact generally provides the simplest and most direct way of distinguishing the different pines.
Needles


THE WHITE PINE (Pinus strobus)

Distinguishing characters: The tree can be told at close range by the number of needles to each cluster. There are five needles to each cluster of the white pine. They are bluish green, slender, and about four inches in length.
White Pine Needles
At a distance the tree may be told by the right angles which the branches form with the main trunk. No other pine shows this character.
Pinus strobus
Form and size: A tall tree, the stateliest of the evergreens.

Range: Eastern North America.
White Pine Range
Soil and location: Prefers a deep, sandy soil, but will grow in almost any soil.

Enemies: Sucking insects forming white downy patches on the bark and twigs, the white pine weevil, a boring insect, and the white pine blister rust, a fungus, are among its principal enemies.
White Pine Weevil and Damage
Value for planting: Aside from its value as an ornamental tree, the white pine is an excellent tree to plant on abandoned farms and for woodlands and windbreaks throughout the New England States, New York, Pennsylvania, and the Lake States.

Commercial value: The wood is easily worked, light, durable, and will not warp. It is used for naval construction, lumber, shingles, laths, interior finish, wooden ware, etc.
White Pine Wood
Other characters: The fruit is a cone, four to six inches long.
White Pine Cone
Comparisons: The tree is apt to be confused with the Bhotan pine (Pinus excelsa - modern name Pinus wallichiana), which is commonly grown as an ornamental tree. The Bhotan pine, however, has needles much longer and more drooping in appearance.
Drooping Bhotan Pine


THE PITCH PINE (Pinus rigida)

Distinguishing characters: Here there are three needles to each cluster. They are dark, yellowish-green needles about four inches long. The rough-looking branches of the tree may be seen studded with cones throughout the year, and clusters of leaves may be seen sprouting directly from the trunk of the tree. The last two are very characteristic and will distinguish the tree at a glance.
Pitch Pine Needles
Form and size: It is a low tree of uncertain habit and extremely rough looking at every stage of its life. It is constantly full of dead branches and old cones which persist on the tree throughout the year.
A Pitch Pine
Range: Eastern United States.
Pitch Pine Range
Soil and location: Grows in the poorest and sandiest soils where few other trees will grow. In New Jersey and on Long Island where it is native, it proves so hardy and persistent that it often forms pure stands excluding other trees.
Poor Growth Conditions
Enemies: None of importance.

Value for planting: Well adapted for the sea coast and other exposed places. It is of extremely uncertain habit and is subject to the loss of the lower limbs. It frequently presents a certain picturesqueness of outline, but it could not be used as a specimen tree on the lawn.

Commercial value: The wood is coarse grained and is used for rough lumber, fuel, and charcoal.

Other characters: The fruit is a cone one to three inches long, persistent on the tree for several years.
Pitch Pine Cone


THE SCOTCH (OR SCOTS) PINE (Pinus sylvestris)

Distinguishing characters: There are two needles to each cluster, and these are short compared with those of the white pine, and slightly twisted. The bark, especially along the upper portion of the trunk, is reddish in color.
Scotch Pine Needles and Cones
Form and size: A medium-sized tree with a short crown.
Scotch Pine
Range: Europe, Asia, and eastern United States.
Range in Europe and Asia
Soil and location: Will do best on a deep, rich, sandy soil, but will also grow on a dry, porous soil.
Scotch Pine
Enemies: In Europe the Scotch pine has several insect enemies, but in America it appears to be free from injury.

Value for planting: Suitable for windbreaks and woodland planting. Many excellent specimens may also be found in our parks.
Scotch Pine
Commercial value: In the United States, the wood is chiefly used for fuel, though slightly used for barrels, boxes, and carpentry. In Europe, the Scotch pine is an important timber tree.
Needles and Cones

Directions

Study the lesson for one week.

Over the week:

  • Read the lesson.
  • Review the synopsis.
  • Recite aloud the vocabulary words and their definitions.
  • Learn the concepts.
  • Complete the enrichment activities.
  • Study the review questions.

Synopsis

This lesson addresses three species of pine trees of the Pinus Genus: the white pine, the pitch pine, and the scotch pine. Pine trees are coniferous trees and therefore bear cones. They are also evergreens, keeping their needles all year-round. Pine trees have long needles in comparison to other types of conifers. White pines have clusters of five needles, pitch pines have three needles in each cluster, and scotch pines have two needles in each cluster. This is unlike the spruce tree (next lesson), where needles connect directly to the branches. The scientific (Latinized) name of the white pine is Pinus strobus, the pitch pine is Pinus rigida, and the scotch pine is Pinus sylvestris.

Vocabulary

Needle: A needle-like leaf found on some conifers.
Conifer: A cone-bearing seed plant, usually a tree.
Fascicle: A cluster of flowers or leaves, such as the bundles of the thin leaves (or needles) of pines.
Surface Area: The total area on the surface of an object.

Concepts

NEEDLES AS LEAVES

Needles are actually thin leaves that are found on some conifers.

Each needle cluster is called a fascicle.

Needles have a thick outer layer called a cuticle, which prevents water loss.

Needles have holes that open and close, called stomata, in their cuticles to uptake carbon dioxide for photosynthesis.

Unlike deciduous trees that lose their leaves each autumn, evergreen trees such as pine trees undergo photosynthesis all year-round.

However, needles have far less surface area than deciduous leaves (pictured), limiting the amount of solar energy they can collect.

Enrichment

Activity 1: Narrate the Lesson

  • After reading or listening to the lesson, narrate the lesson aloud using your own words.

Activity 2: Study the Lesson Pictures

  • Study the lesson pictures and describe how they relate to the lesson.

Activity 3: Take a Nature Walk

  • Bring a small sketchbook and embark on a nature walk.
  • Search for any type of pine tree. If you cannot find a pine tree, choose another evergreen tree to study.
  • Study and sketch the appearance, habitat, and cones of the tree.
  • Count the number of needles per fascicle. Do your tree's fascicles have five needles like a white pine, three like a pitch pine, or two like a scotch pine?
  • Collect a needle cluster specimen from the tree.
  • Use the sketch and leaf specimen to create the field book entry.

Activity 4: Complete a Field Book Entry   

After your nature walk, complete page 43 in 'Science Field Book for Fourth Grade.'

Review

Question 1

What is a pine fascicle?
1 / 6

Answer 1

A pine fascicle is a cluster of pine needles.
1 / 6

Question 2

How can you tell a white pine, a pitch pine, and a scotch pine apart?
2 / 6

Answer 2

You can tell a white pine, a pitch pine, and a scotch pine apart from the number of needles per fascicle.
2 / 6

Question 3

What are the leaves of evergreen plants?
3 / 6

Answer 3

The leaves of evergreen plants are the needles.
3 / 6

Question 4

Do evergreen trees undergo photosynthesis?
4 / 6

Answer 4

Yes, evergreen trees undergo photosynthesis year-round.
4 / 6

Question 5

Do evergreen trees have stomata to intake carbon dioxide?
5 / 6

Answer 5

Yes, evergreen trees have stomata to intake carbon dioxide.
5 / 6

Question 6

Why can't evergreen tree leaves (needles) collect as much sun energy as deciduous tree leaves?
6 / 6

Answer 6

Evergreen tree leaves (needles) are thinner and have less surface area than deciduous tree leaves.
6 / 6

  1. What is a pine fascicle? A pine fascicle is a cluster of pine needles.
  2. How can you tell a white pine, a pitch pine, and a scotch pine apart? You can tell a white pine, a pitch pine, and a scotch pine apart from the number of needles per fascicle.
  3. What are the leaves of evergreen plants? The leaves of evergreen plants are the needles.
  4. Do evergreen trees undergo photosynthesis? Yes, evergreen trees undergo photosynthesis year-round.
  5. Do evergreen trees have stomata to intake carbon dioxide? Yes, evergreen trees have stomata to intake carbon dioxide.
  6. Why can't evergreen tree leaves (needles) collect as much sun energy as deciduous tree leaves? Evergreen tree leaves (needles) are thinner and have less surface area than deciduous tree leaves.

References

  1. 'Studies of Trees' by Jacob Joshua Levison. gutenberg.org/ebooks/16116. n.p.
  2. 'Pine.' Wikipedia. Wikipedia.org. n.p.
  3. 'Evergreen.' Wikipedia. Wikipedia.org. n.p.